The new Angel's regime made it's first move Wednesday night, by trading away Tyler Chatwood to the Rockies for Chris Iannetta. It seems like it's finally apparent to the Angels that Jeff Mathis isn't a Major League catcher, and represented the biggest hole on the roster. The deal is a huge win for the Angels, as they get a catcher who can get on base as a good clip, and has enough power to hit 20 home runs, even in The Big A.
Iannetta has never really gotten an opportunity to get consistent playing time in Colorado. He's been bounced between the majors and minors throughout his career. He's also has an injury history, which is a red flag for a catcher. Iannetta has a career walk rate of 14%, but I'd expect that to drop in the American League because of the better pitching, and because he won't be hitting in front of the pitcher anymore. Iannetta didn't have a future with the Rockies, and the move was probably the best thing for both him and the club.
As a result, I don't think it's out of the question that the Angels could carry three catchers on their roster to open up next season. Up-and-comer Hank Conger bears a similar profile to Iannetta, and doesn't need anymore time in the minors. Conger's defense is suspect, but he hits enough to be used at catcher and possibly at designated hitter. Jeff Mathis is the only one who I believe is in danger of losing his roster spot. He doesn't hit enough, and his defense seems to be overstated. That said, he is still probably the best defensive catcher on the roster, and that's still something that Mike Scoscia values.
In return for Iannetta, the Rockies receive Tyler Chatwood. Chatwood made 25 starts last year, at the age of 21. He wasn't ready for the big leagues, and struggled to keep his ERA under five. His K/BB ratio was barely above 1, and he benefited from his park and the defense behind him. I don't think he has much upside, and I think he'll struggle in Coors Field. The Rockies will start him in the rotation, but I wouldn't be surprised if he ended up in the bullpen.
To replace Iannetta behind the plate, the Rockies signed free agent Ramon Hernandez. Hernandez will be 36 next year, but brings average defense, solid contact skills, decent on base skills, and could hit 15 home runs in Colorado. He had a disappointing second half in 2011, but put up a composite .280/.348/.413 line during his three seasons in Cincinnati. Hernandez will serve as a stop gap for the Rockies until Wilon Rosario is ready. Rosario is a top prospect in the Rockies system, but hasn't been to Class-AAA yet. His bat show promise, but has developed slowly. He should start 2012 in AAA, and could be up by the end of the year, but I would be surprised if he got more than a cup of coffee in 2012.
Iannetta is still under team control through 2013, and Colorado decided to move him to open up the position for whenever Rosario is ready. The Angels fixed their hole at catcher by acquiring Mike Napoli light, and only gave up a back-end starter in the process. Anaheim is in line to have their highest payroll ever this season (thank you Vernon Wells), but it looks like as a result of this move, they'll have to acquire a starting pitcher. They have a solid top three with Jered Weaver, Dan Haren, and Ervin Santana, but were relying on Chatwood and Jerome Williams in the back-end, with little depth. They've been talking to C.J. Wilson, but I'd expect them to settle for a lesser guy due to financial constraints. Their ballpark and defense also allows them to hide the deficiencies of lesser pitchers.