On Tuesday afternoon, Prince Fielder, Scott Boras, and the Detroit Tigers put baseball on it's ear. After not being in on any of the Fielder rumors during this offseason, the Tigers jumped in at the last minute and signed the big first baseman to a nine year $214 million deal.
The Mystery Team was two for two this offseason in signing big time first baseman, as the Angels swooped in earlier this offseason to sign Albert Pujols out of nowhere. This has been something of a recent trend, at least for top end free agents, with the Phillies doing the same thing with Cliff Lee last year.
The deal itself seems to be a little bit of an overpay. The AAV is $23.8 million, putting Fielder up with the top earners in the league. He also gets nine years out of the Tigers, while other clubs were hesitant to go to seven or eight years. But after losing Victor Martinez, the team needed another bat, and owner Mike Ilitch was willing to spend. No one else on the market could fill in the hole left by Victor Martinez, except for Prince Fielder.
All of the other possible replacements (Johnny Damon, Hideki Matsui, Vladamir Guerrero, etc.), though, would have only required one year deals. Meaning that they'd be off the books when Victor Martinez returns in 2013. With Fielder signing a nine year deal though, the Tigers will have themselves a logjam at first base and designated hitter for the final two years of Victor Martinez's contract.
Shortly after the deal was signed, Miguel Cabrera said he would shift back over to third, and people actually think that could be a possibility. The last time Cabrera played any third was his first year in Detroit, 2008. Since then, he's been exclusively at first base, and has gained weight. That year, 2008, Miggy played all of 14 games at third before the team was forced to move him to first. He's not going to be any better in 2012, and probably would be substantially worse. Both Miguel Cabrera and Prince Fielder are first base or designated hitters, they can't play anywhere else. Victor Martinez, on the other hand, has the ability to play bad catcher. That won't alleviate many of the Tigers' issues in 2012 though, because Alex Avila emerged last season as a Big League catcher.
It appears that the Tigers' will indeed have three players for two spots in the lineup. The easiest way to fix this problem would be with a trade. In which case Victor Martinez would be the most likely to be traded. He's got the least years left on his deal, the littlest money owed, so other teams would be more willing to take him on. He's also now the least valuable to the trio to the Tigers.
There are other negatives to this deal for the Tigers, besides the impending logjam. By acquiring another 1B/DH type, they take a real hit on defense. They're going to constantly have two of Delmon Young, Miguel Cabrera, and Prince Fielder in the field this season. In 2013, if they don't retain Young who will be a free agent next offseason, they have the same problem with Victor Martinez, who is a poor defender but can't play outfield. They also limit their flexibility, since they're going to have a line of people for the DH slot at all times. They won't be able to use it to rest players or ease them back from injury.
The final "negative" from this deal is that it actually doesn't make them that much better, at least in 2012. Victor Martinez was a three win player last year for the Tigers, and Prince doesn't project to be more than a five win player, and possibly less if his power doesn't translate outside of Miller Park. Adding Prince only makes them two wins better then they were in 2011, and will create a numbers problem further down the road.
But as an Indians fan, I can't help but think how this will affect the rest of the division. I don't think it changes the plans of either the White Sox or Twins that much. They aren't looking to make too much noise in 2012, and both teams, as well as Detroit, could look different before they are both playing for something.
For the Royals, I could see how this could keep them from making any more moves. I believe that the Royals were still trying to add a starting pitcher, and try to take the league by storm from under the radar in 2012. If their young hitters took a step forward, and their young pitchers took the step forward that most of them didn't in 2011, they could have surprised some people. Instead, I think the Fielder signing might persuade them to wait a year, bide their time, save a little payroll this year (which doesn't just get put into a fire like some people seem to think, that's money that they can still spend next season), and hopefully come into 2013 a little stronger than they otherwise would.
For the Indians, this signing was close to worst case scenario, but then again, it's Cleveland, so that should be expected. This Indians team was built to try and win in 2012 and 2013, the time where the Tigers have all of their stars in their prime. This should force the Indians into making some sort of move this offseason. Whether that's signing Casey Kotchman or trading for Carlos Lee, the Indians need to do something if they're serious about winning. Because the team that beat them last season just got better, and they haven't gotten any better, and could have possibly gotten worse depending on how you feel about the pitcher formerly known as Fausto Carmona.
This move for the Tigers came out of nowhere, and understandably. It doesn't seem to make much sense for their roster, and they didn't have a reason to be attached to Fielder in any way before the Victor Martinez injury. This is clearly a reactionary move, while signing a big name always sounds good in the short term, it often doesn't work out in the end. The Tigers weren't the best fit for Fielder, and it'll be interesting seeing how they manage their roster moving forward.